Does anyone have a guess how to attract them specifically?  I've been stuck on this dang "nuts" quest for almost a week and, unfortunately, a black squirrel showed up and took one of the slots but I haven't been able to attract a 2nd.  I tried a plate of superfood, adding a 2nd bonsai, adding a bells and now a 2nd one and all I've gotten are a TON of grey squirrels!  No BS!!!  If anyone's had good luck attracting them and can let me in on their secret, I'd appreciate it.  This quest is MAKING ME NUTS!!!!  Thank you very much for "listening" to my sad story.  XO

There is no secret.  If you're set up for grey ones, and they are coming easily, then black ones can come.

I had exactly the same issue Cj, It took 3 days for my BS to arrive. And I am now waiting for a griffin lol. A Griffin!
Hope he comes soon for you!

i was like that it will come

Now that your low plate is empty, replace it with a high table. It won't "attract" them any quicker but it will eliminate 2 of the mice which might show up.

Thank you all for sharing thoughts and experiences on my black squirrel problem... will try changing plates, Dorothy, AND being patient (not so easy!).  Happy hunting, all.  VK&H

I know. I am not looking forward to doing the 2 black 2 albino quest at all as I also have a patience issue. lol